Monday, June 27, 2005
Friendster
I'll assume that Joe Mohan is T. McGee, but I'll answer anyways...
1) I disagree with the result. Partially because it directly conflicts with my research, however, I will give a relevant example...
The argument as I understand it is that peer to peer (p2p) is that it makes it too easy to trade copyrighted material. The problem is stating what is too easy, let's pretend that I want a picture of angelina jolie. I could do a google image search that returns a copyrighted picture of angelina jolie, but does that make google liable? (I really hope that the answer is no)
Also, I hate the idea of p2p protocols being illegal, since I would like to use p2p protocols for good (distributing physics information to researcher) rather than evil. But hypothetically they could be used for evil, so are they illegal?
2) I take it back, I think this is JP, since he is the torrent master. But now that you mention it, torrent might be considered seperatly, since there is no direct network for finding a torrent (which is the main function of a p2p network) then technically torrents should be in a seperate class unless you consider torrent networks dangerous since content can distrubuted more quickly but not more efficiently.
As for implications, this might be a killer for my research, since right now I am looking at replica management (moving data closer to clients and how to reliable find replicas) and this is a common function of p2p systems that needs to be improved. (replica management would give you the closest copy of britney spear's baby one more time without your intervention)
Friendship
1) I disagree with the result. Partially because it directly conflicts with my research, however, I will give a relevant example...
The argument as I understand it is that peer to peer (p2p) is that it makes it too easy to trade copyrighted material. The problem is stating what is too easy, let's pretend that I want a picture of angelina jolie. I could do a google image search that returns a copyrighted picture of angelina jolie, but does that make google liable? (I really hope that the answer is no)
Also, I hate the idea of p2p protocols being illegal, since I would like to use p2p protocols for good (distributing physics information to researcher) rather than evil. But hypothetically they could be used for evil, so are they illegal?
2) I take it back, I think this is JP, since he is the torrent master. But now that you mention it, torrent might be considered seperatly, since there is no direct network for finding a torrent (which is the main function of a p2p network) then technically torrents should be in a seperate class unless you consider torrent networks dangerous since content can distrubuted more quickly but not more efficiently.
As for implications, this might be a killer for my research, since right now I am looking at replica management (moving data closer to clients and how to reliable find replicas) and this is a common function of p2p systems that needs to be improved. (replica management would give you the closest copy of britney spear's baby one more time without your intervention)
Friendship